FC United booked an FA Trophy third qualifying-round date with Altrincham by seeing off Durham at the second attempt at Gigg Lane.
But the Rebels needed extra-time to secure their passage with substitutes Jimmy Holden and Astley Mulholland each scoring in the added half-hour to earn them a 3-1 victory.
Mike Norton put them in front in the first half but Amar Purewal poked Durham level soon after the break.
:: Witton Albion secured a Trophy trip to Droylsden with Anthony Sheehan, Alex Titchiner, Daniel Andrews and Josh Hancock on target in a 4-1 romp over Leek.
Radcliffe crashed 2-0 at Worksop, who next host Curzon Ashton.